Skip to Main Content
view cart 0
Black Friday

Things to Consider When Shopping for a Mattress

Shopping For a Mattress

There's a lot of terminology and lingo that are thrown around regarding mattresses, making it tough to sort through to find a matress that's going to help you wake up feeling refreshed in the morning. There's no "one mattress fits all" solution to sleep as we all have different bodies, sleep differently, and live different lifestyles. So here at Pilgrim Furniture City, we decided to take it back to the basics to help you start your mattress shopping journey. We've put together a number of basic questions you should consider as you start looking for the best nights sleep.

Who will be sleeping on the mattress?

Who's Sleeping On the Mattress

Who's sleeping in the bed is the first thing you should think about when looking for a new mattress. This will impact everything from what size of mattress is right for you to what sort of firmness is right. Is the bed for your child, for you, or for you and a significant other?

What's your budget?

what's your mattress budget

Determining how much you are willing to spend on your new mattress can be a tricky process. While it's not as flashy or as fun of a purchase as buying a new car, your mattress is one of the most important investments you can make. How you sleep impacts everything from your job performance to your mood and energy with friends and family.

What size mattress is right for your needs?

Kids Bed

Mattress for a Child - If you're looking for a mattress for a child, you should look for a twin or full mattress. Twin mattresses are narrow and fit well in smaller bedrooms as well as tending to be less expensive than larger mattresses. Full mattresses offer a bit more space, allowing your child to grow into the bed.

Adult Bed

Mattress for Adults - For many adults, a Queen mattress is going to provide plenty of space to get comfortable. Queen mattresses are the most commonly available and are easier to move than larger mattresses. King mattresses offer extra width for you and your partner to have ample room while California King mattresses offer extra length for taller people.

How do you sleep?

Mattress For Side Sleeper

Side Sleeper - If you’re a side sleeper you will likely find your best night's sleep on a more plush mattress that allows your shoulders and hips to sink into the mattress a little bit. This give from the mattress allows your hip to drop down a bit and allows your spine to properly align.

Mattress For Back Sleeper

Back Sleeper - If you’re a back sleeper you will likely find your best night’s sleep on a more plush mattress that allows your hips to sink in a little bit and allow your spine to properly align. If a mattress is too firm you will likely feel uncomfortable points of pressure similar to the pain many of us feel after sitting in a car for a long drive.

Mattress For Stomach Sleeper

Stomach Sleeper - If you’re a stomach sleeper then your best night's sleep will likely come from a firmer mattress. Unlike back and side sleeper’s you’re already putting yourself in a position where your spine is aligned. This means that a mattress with more give will actually cause your spine to slump a bit which could lead to you waking up with back pain.

Mattress Tossing & Turning Sleeper

Tossing & Turning - Don't fit into any of the other categories because you spend your nights tossing and turning? Don't worry, there are still plenty of mattresses to help you get your best night's sleep! Because you may sleep on your back, side, and stomach all in the same night, you'll likely wake up feeling the most refreshed with a more balanced, medium, mattress that is somewhere between firm and plush.

Do you wake up with pain?

Mattress For Hip Pain

Hip Pain - Are you waking up each morning with hip pain? Hip pain is likely the result of a mattress that isn't providing your hips with proper support. This can be a result of anything from a mattress that is too soft or too firm or simply a worn out mattress. To help reduce your hip pain in the morning consider investing in a more plush mattress than can adjust to the contours of your body. Shop Plush Mattresses

Mattress For Back Pain

Back Pain - Most often caused by a worn out mattress that is no longer capable of providing you with the support you need. Like slumping at your desk or while watching tv, slumping will likely cause back pain; preventing you from getting a full night's sleep and contributing to back pain. As coils age they lose their ability to bounce back from weight being put on them night after night, resulting in a slumping mattress as they don’t have the same rigidity they once had, and need, in order to properly function.

This slumping doesn’t just apply to coil mattresses though, the same slumping issue is also true of foam mattresses. Slumping in foam mattresses is often easy to diagnose as the mattress will show visible signs of slumping while coil mattresses may not. To find the perfect mattress for your perfect night’s sleep come see our experts!

Mattress For Neck Pain

Neck Pain - Unlike back pain, neck pain is most commonly caused by your pillow, not your mattress. The pillow’s responsibility is to align your neck with your spine while you sleep. There are two key factors that go into why your pillow may have become a pain for your neck. The first is that the pillow has simply become worn out.

The other key factor to consider with your neck pain is did you select the right type of pillow for how you sleep? Depending on if you’re a side, back, or stomach sleeper the perfect pillow for you will change. Even the most expensive pillow can leave you waking up with pain in your neck if it doesn’t fit your sleep style. To find the perfect pillow for you, come see our experts or start by start shopping online.

How firm or plush of a mattress do you sleep best on?

If you don't deal with pain when you awake each morning, getting to sleep is likely your top priority. Everyone's body is unique, so your perfect ammount of firmness, softness, or balance between the two is likely to vary, so trying out a mattress for yourself in store is the best route to find a bed that is just right.

Plush Mattress

Plush - Do you sleep best on a softer, more plush, mattress? If so, we reccomend looking for any of the following types of mattress (listed from most plush to more balanced): Box Top, Super Pillow Top, Euro Top, Pillow Top, or Plush. Shopping for a plush mattress can be more challenging than shopping for firmer mattresses as once you lay down on a plush mattress, it may be easy to feel that it is perfectly comfortable but if you were to spend more time on the mattress you may find it doesn't provide the support you need. To avoid this issue, we reccomend spending ~10 minutes laying on the mattress in store to really get a good feel for what kind of comfort and support the mattress offers. Shop Plush Mattresses

Medium Mattress

Medium - If you sleep best on a more balanced mattress, we recommend seeking out a Plush, Cushion Firm, or even a Firm mattress. Both Plush and Firm mattresses can offer what you may consider a balanced feel, so we recommend keeping them on the table until you have a chance to lay on them for yourself. Like with any other type of mattress your best bet at ensuring a mattress will provide both the comfort and support you need each night, recommend spending ~10 minutes laying on the mattress in store. Shop Medium Mattresses

Firm Mattress

Firm - Does your best night's sleep come from a firmer mattress? We reccomend looking for a Cushion Firm, Firm, or Extra Firm mattress. How firm a mattress feels to you will be affected by factors ranging from personal preference to your body type so it is important to test out mattresses in store to ensure it will be up to your standards and provide proper comfort and support for your unique needs. Shop Firm Mattresses

Do you sleep warm or cool?

Warm Sleeper

Warm Sleeper - Do you wake up drenched in sweat or struggle to even fall asleep because you're too warm? Recent technologic advances in sleep technology may be able to provide a solution for you. New technology and materials offer features such as moisture wicking, enhanced ariflow, and decreased heat retention to help you sleep comfortably. Even products that previously were known to sleep warm, such as memory foam mattresses and pillows, have incorporated new technologies and materials to provide you with the best nights sleep.

Cool Sleeper

Cool Sleeper - Do you have a tendency to wake up in the morning or even the middle of the night freezing? While heated mattresses are not an option, you may want to consider an adjustable base for your mattress. Adjustable bases can help with circulation to help prevent your extremeties from getting too cold at night. You could also consider purchasing thicker blankets to help retain your body heat better as you sleep.

How to Test a Mattress In Store

Test
  • Select a pillow to test mattresses with that's designed to provide proper support for how you sleep
  • Pick a mattress to test out and try it out for ~10 minutes
  • Lay down how you would normally sleep in your own bed
  • Determine whether the level and support are in line with your wants and needs
  • Try out a number of other mattresses to compare the comfort and support of each
  • If you sleep with a significant other you should try the mattresses together to help ensure the best fit for both of you

Besides sleeping, how do you use your mattress?

For the best nights sleep possible, check out our Sleep Health and Habits Guide. To learn more about Adjustable Bases and their benefits, read our Adjustable Base Buying Guide.

TV in Bed

Watching TV - If you enjoy catching up on the day's news or unwinding with your favorite show before you go to bed, you should likely consider investing in an adjustable base bed. An adjustable base bed allows you to raise your head to prevent neck strain as you relax with your show.

Working From Home

Working - It's never been easier to work from the comfort of your own bed, with laptops, tablets, and even smartphones making it all to easy to check email, put together a quick report, or whatever else your job requires from bed, it's easy to overstrain your neck or back. Adding an adjustable base to your home can not only help to reduce strain but many adjustable bases come with built-in USB ports and/or power outlets to keep yoru devices charged while you power through some quick work.

Reading in Bed

Reading - From news on your phone to a good old paperback book, reading in bed is a good way to relax before hitting the hay for many. Finding that perfect angle that provides both comfort and support as you take in your pre-sleep reading material can be a challenge, no matter how many pillows you have to stack up behind your neck and back. Adjustable bases once again provide a solution to this age old problem, allowing you to find the perfect angle with the touch of a button.

Shop Mattresses

Queen 17 1/2" Premium Adj Set
Queen 17 1/2" Premium Adj SetK-Class Firm PT collection
Compare At $8,525.00
Sale Price $6,089.00*
$10,059.98
On Display
Queen 12" Pocketed Coil Mattress
Queen 12" Pocketed Coil MattressBR800 Plush ET collection
Compare At $1,060.00
Sale Price $636.00*
$2,019.99
On Display
Queen 15 3/4" Plush Pillow Top Mattress
Queen 15 3/4" Plush Pillow Top MattressCarbon Series Plush PT collection
Compare At $3,331.00
Sale Price $1,999.00*
On Display
Queen 13 3/4" Plush Adj Set
Queen 13 3/4" Plush Adj SetCarbon Series Plush collection
Compare At $4,588.00
Sale Price $2,753.00*
On Display
Queen 9" Biltmore Foundation
Queen 9" Biltmore FoundationBiltmore Foundations II collection
Compare At $350.00
Sale Price $210.00*
On Display
Queen 14" Premium Pocketed Coil Adj Set
Queen 14" Premium Pocketed Coil Adj SetL-Class Plush collection
Compare At $8,258.00
Sale Price $5,898.00*
$9,299.98
On Display
Queen 11" Firm Hybrid Mattress
Queen 11" Firm Hybrid MattressRussell Firm Hybrid collection
Compare At $3,500.00
Sale Price $2,100.00*
On Display
Queen 13 3/4" Medium Adj Set
Queen 13 3/4" Medium Adj SetCarbon Series Medium collection
Compare At $4,588.00
Sale Price $2,753.00*
On Display
Queen 9" Foundation
Queen 9" FoundationDream Haven 2019 Foundations collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen Motion Air™ Adjustable Foundation
Queen Motion Air™ Adjustable FoundationBeautyrest Motion Air collection
Compare At $1,060.00
Sale Price $636.00*
On Display
Queen 9" Regular Foundation
Queen 9" Regular Foundation2019 iComfort Foundations collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 10" Medium Firm Mattress
Queen 10" Medium Firm MattressiComfort CF1000 Med collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 12 1/2" Firm Hybrid Mattress Set
Queen 12 1/2" Firm Hybrid Mattress SetCF2000 Hybrid Firm collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 9" BR Black Foundation
Queen 9" BR Black FoundationBR Black 2019 Foundations collection
Compare At $300.00
Sale Price $180.00*
$579.99
On Display
Queen Luxury Adjustable Base
Queen Luxury Adjustable BaseBR Black Luxury Base collection
Compare At $2,999.00
Sale Price $1,800.00*
$5,879.99
On Display
Queen Motion Essentials IV Adjustable Base
Queen Motion Essentials IV Adjustable BaseMotion Essentials IV collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 12" High Performance Foam Mattress
Queen 12" High Performance Foam MattressiMattress Lexie collection
Compare At $1,832.00
Sale Price $1,100.00*
On Display
Queen SL Universal High Profile Foundation
Queen SL Universal High Profile FoundationScott Living Foundations collection
Compare At $335.00
Sale Price $201.00*
$499.99
On Display
Twin XL 9" Foam Low Profile Set
Twin XL 9" Foam Low Profile SetiMattress Aly collection
Compare At $970.00
Sale Price $582.00*
On Display
Full 13 1/2" Medium Feel Hybrid Mattress
Full 13 1/2" Medium Feel Hybrid MattressX-Class Hybrid Medium collection
Compare At $3,681.00
Sale Price $2,629.00*
$4,759.99
On Display
Twin 12" Pocketed Coil Mattress
Twin 12" Pocketed Coil MattressBR800 Medium collection
Compare At $660.00
Sale Price $396.00*
On Display
Twin XL 9" Foundation
Twin XL 9" FoundationPerfect Sleeper Foundations collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 12" Foam Mattress
Queen 12" Foam MattressWoodridge Foam collection
Compare At $610.00
On Display
Queen 12 1/2" Medium Firm Adj Set
Queen 12 1/2" Medium Firm Adj SetMaui Series Med Firm collection
Compare At $2,558.00
Sale Price $1,535.00*
On Display
Queen 16 1/2" Pocketed Coil Adjustable Set
Queen 16 1/2" Pocketed Coil Adjustable SetBRS900-C Plush PT collection
Compare At $2,830.00
Sale Price $1,698.00*
$5,259.98
On Display
Queen 13 3/4" Premium Adj Set
Queen 13 3/4" Premium Adj SetL-Class Extra Firm collection
Compare At $5,123.00
Sale Price $3,659.00*
$5,439.98
On Display
Queen Power Base
Queen Power BasePB475 Power Bases collection
Compare At $1,339.00
Sale Price $804.00*
$2,529.99
On Display
Queen 14 1/4" Premium Mattress Set
Queen 14 1/4" Premium Mattress SetL-Class Medium collection
Compare At $4,479.00
Sale Price $3,199.00*
$4,759.98
On Display
Queen Head Only Adjustable Base
Queen Head Only Adjustable BasePGT Adjustable Metal Base collection
Compare At $639.00
Sale Price $384.00*
On Display
Queen 12" Extra Firm Mattress
Queen 12" Extra Firm MattressPineview XF collection
Compare At $1,190.00
Sale Price $717.00*
$2,269.99
On Display
Queen 12" Medium Hybrid Mattress Set
Queen 12" Medium Hybrid Mattress SetCF1000 Hybrid Medium collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 11 1/2" Firm Memory Foam Adj Set
Queen 11 1/2" Firm Memory Foam Adj SetiComfort CF2000 Firm collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen 15 1/2" Medium Pillow Top Mattress
Queen 15 1/2" Medium Pillow Top MattressCayman Series Medium PT collection
Compare At $1,998.00
Sale Price $1,199.00*
On Display
Queen 12" Medium Smartlife Mattress
Queen 12" Medium Smartlife MattressLily Medium collection
Sale Price $4,799.00*
On Display
Queen 14 1/2" Plush Pillow Top Adj Set
Queen 14 1/2" Plush Pillow Top Adj SetMaui Series Plush PT collection
Compare At $2,725.00
Sale Price $1,635.00*
On Display
Queen 11 1/4" Pocketed Coil Mattress
Queen 11 1/4" Pocketed Coil MattressBR800 Firm collection
Compare At $790.00
Sale Price $474.00*
On Display
Queen Pocketed Coil Mattress
Queen Pocketed Coil MattressLuxe Edition Grandmere Plush PT collection
On Display Contact Us For Pricing
Queen Adjustable Base
Queen Adjustable BaseFE3500 Adj Base collection
Compare At $1,579.00
Sale Price $948.00*
On Display
Queen 9" Innerspring Mattress
Queen 9" Innerspring MattressSimona Firm collection
Compare At $500.00
Sale Price $300.00*
$959.99
On Display
Queen 13 1/2" Extra Firm Adj Set
Queen 13 1/2" Extra Firm Adj SetCarbon Extra Firm collection
Compare At $4,255.00
Sale Price $2,553.00*
On Display
Queen 13" Extra Firm Mattress
Queen 13" Extra Firm MattressCayman Series Extra Firm collection
Compare At $1,831.00
Sale Price $1,099.00*
On Display
King 13 3/4" Premium Mattress Set
King 13 3/4" Premium Mattress SetC-Class Medium collection
Compare At $6,811.00
Sale Price $4,865.00*
$7,199.97
On Display
Split King 9" Foundation
Split King 9" Foundation2019 Beautyrest Foundations collection
Compare At $666.00
Sale Price $400.00*
On Display
Twin XL 5" Low Profile BR Black Foundation
Twin XL 5" Low Profile BR Black FoundationBR Black 2019 Foundations collection
Compare At $250.00
Sale Price $150.00*
$419.99
On Display
Full 14" Extra Firm Euro Top Mattress
Full 14" Extra Firm Euro Top MattressRexford XF ET collection
Compare At $3,679.00
Sale Price $2,208.00*
$6,179.99
On Display
Full 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Full 10" Memory Foam MattressM699 Chime 10 collection
Compare At $530.00
Sale Price $318.00*
$1,009.99
On Display
Queen 15 3/4" Premium Adj Set
Queen 15 3/4" Premium Adj SetL-Class Medium Pillow Top collection
Compare At $6,705.00
Sale Price $4,789.00*
$7,589.98
Available to Order
Queen 13 3/4" Premium Adj Set
Queen 13 3/4" Premium Adj SetC-Class Plush collection
Compare At $7,125.00
Sale Price $5,089.00*
$8,159.98
Available to Order
Queen 16" Premium Mattress Set
Queen 16" Premium Mattress SetC-Class Plush PT collection
Compare At $5,763.00
Sale Price $4,116.00*
$8,089.98
Available to Order
Queen 14" Plush Hybrid Mattress Set
Queen 14" Plush Hybrid Mattress SetCF4000 Hybrid Plush collection
Available to Order Contact Us For Pricing